Quick Explainer: What Is the DGA and Why It Matters
The Directors Guild of America (DGA) has
been presenting its Theatrical Feature Film Directing Award since
the late 1940s.
With thousands of working directors and assistant directors
voting, it’s one of the largest and most unified voting bodies in Hollywood.
Historically, the DGA winner almost always goes on to win the Best
Director Oscar.
That’s why when the Academy picks someone else—or even
leaves the DGA winner out of the Oscar nominations entirely—it
becomes a major piece of awards‑season drama.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The Classic Early Mismatches
Let’s start with a few of the classic early mismatches
between the DGA Awards and the Oscars.
1968:
Anthony Harvey wins the DGA for The Lion in Winter, but the
directing Oscar goes to Carol Reed for Oliver!,
which also wins Best Picture.
This is one of the first clear examples where Oscar voters leaned into a more
traditional, crowd‑pleasing musical, while directors recognized a darker, more
character‑driven film.
1972:
Francis Ford Coppola wins the DGA for The Godfather, yet the Oscar
goes to Bob Fosse for Cabaret.
Here, The Godfather still takes Best Picture, but the Academy
singles out Fosse’s stylized, innovative direction—showing that the directors’
branch sometimes rewards pure directorial flair over the overall Best Picture
juggernaut.
1985:
Steven Spielberg wins the DGA for The Color Purple but isn’t
even nominated for Best Director at the Oscars.
Sydney Pollack wins instead for Out of Africa, which
also takes Best Picture.
This is one of the most famous early snubs—DGA voters back Spielberg, but the
Academy not only rejects his win, they exclude him entirely from the category.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The Modern Anomalies
In the modern era, these splits become even more fascinating
because they happen so rarely.
1995:
Ron Howard wins the DGA for Apollo 13 but, like Spielberg, he
misses an Oscar nomination.
Mel Gibson wins the directing Oscar for Braveheart,
which also wins Best Picture.
Apollo 13 was a major hit and a technical achievement, but the
Academy went all‑in on the more traditional historical epic.
2000:
Ang Lee wins the DGA for Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon,
a wuxia romance that becomes a global phenomenon and a landmark for Asian
cinema.
He loses the directing Oscar to Steven Soderbergh for Traffic,
who was also nominated that same year for Erin Brockovich.
At the Oscars, Crouching Tiger wins multiple awards but misses
Best Director and Best Picture, while the Academy rewards Soderbergh’s gritty,
multi‑narrative drug‑war drama as the more urgent, contemporary achievement.
2002:
Rob Marshall wins the DGA for Chicago, but the Oscar
goes to Roman Polanski for The Pianist,
while Chicago still wins Best Picture.
This is a classic split: the more populist musical wins the Guild and Best
Picture, while the more intimate Holocaust drama wins Best Director.
2012:
Ben Affleck wins the DGA for Argo, yet he isn’t even
nominated for Best Director at the Oscars.
The Oscar instead goes to Ang Lee for Life of Pi.
In one of the most talked‑about snubs ever, the Academy’s directors branch
leaves Affleck off the ballot, while Argo still goes on to win
Best Picture.
This proved the DGA’s strength as a predictor of industry respect, even when
the smaller Oscar branch made a different call.
2019:
Sam Mendes wins the DGA for 1917, a technical tour‑de‑force,
but the directing Oscar goes to Bong Joon-ho for Parasite.
The Guild backs the ambitious war film shot to look like one continuous take,
while the Academy makes history by rewarding the first non‑English‑language
film to win both Best Picture and Best Director.
You can see a pattern: when the DGA and Oscars split, the
DGA often backs the big craft showcase or presumed front‑runner, while Oscar
voters sometimes pivot to a more daring or emotionally resonant choice—or, in
Ben Affleck and Ron Howard’s cases, leave the DGA winner out entirely.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
How Rare Is Disagreement, Really?
Across the full history of the DGA Awards, only
a small handful of winners have failed to convert to an Oscar Best
Director win.
One analysis notes that in over 70 years of the DGA
Awards, only about seven DGA winners have lost the directing
Oscar, and several of those weren’t even nominated.
In the last 20 years, the alignment rate has hovered
around 90%, which is why every new split becomes a headline story
and a key talking point for awards predictors.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
What These Splits Tell Us
So what do these rare disagreements actually reveal?
First, scale:
The DGA is a much larger group—around 16,000 members—while the Oscars’
Directors Branch is only a few hundred people. That smaller size makes it
easier for the Academy to make idiosyncratic or personal choices.
Second, emphasis:
The DGA tends to reward the “best directed” film from a technical standpoint,
while Oscar decisions can be swayed by narratives about career recognition,
controversy, or the Best Picture race itself.
That’s why, for predictions, many awards watchers treat the
DGA as a near‑lock but always leave room for a surprise.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
📢 Subscribe & Follow
Now it’s your turn:
Which DGA vs Oscar split do you think was the most shocking?
Was it Ben Affleck for Argo, Sam Mendes
for 1917, Steven Spielberg for The Color Purple,
or another one entirely?
Drop your pick in the comments below — and subscribe
to Cinema
Awards Archive for more deep‑dive breakdowns on how guilds,
critics, and the Academy align (or clash) every awards season.
Don’t forget to follow our blog for weekly posts about Oscar
history, film awards records, and cinematic milestones!
